In This Article
In this article
India’s Concerns Heard at US Meet
Last week, India’s concerns about cross-border terror were raised at a high-level meeting in the US. The Indian delegation pointed out that radical Islamist extremism poses a significant threat not just to India, but to the entire region. This concern is not new, but the fact that it was raised at a meeting attended by US lawmakers, including Senator Marco Rubio, is significant. According to a report by ORF Online, India has been consistently raising the issue of cross-border terror with its international partners. In fact, data from the South Asia Terrorism Portal shows that between 2018 and 2022, there were over 2,300 terror attacks in Jammu and Kashmir, resulting in the death of over 1,500 security personnel and civilians.
A specific data point that highlights the threat is the number of terror attacks in Jammu and Kashmir. In 2022, there were over 100 terror attacks in the region, resulting in the death of dozens of security personnel and civilians. This number has been consistently rising over the past few years, with 2022 seeing a 25% increase in terror attacks compared to the previous year. As America’s Geriatric Government: What It Means for India’s Defence notes, the threat of cross-border terror is a major concern for India’s national security. Furthermore, a report by the Institute of Peace and Conflict Studies notes that the threat of radical Islamist extremism is not limited to Jammu and Kashmir, but also extends to other parts of India, including the northeastern states.
Rubio’s Response Raises Eyebrows
However, Senator Rubio’s response to India’s concerns has raised eyebrows. While acknowledging the threat of terrorism, Rubio downplayed the role of radical Islamist extremism. This is surprising, given that the US has itself been a victim of radical Islamist terror in the past. The 9/11 attacks, which took place in 2001, were carried out by radical Islamist terrorists, resulting in the death of over 3,000 people. As the United Nations notes, the threat of radical Islamist extremism is a global concern that requires a coordinated response. In fact, a report by the Counter Extremism Project notes that radical Islamist extremism is a major threat to global security, with over 30,000 radical Islamist terrorists operating in over 100 countries.
Historically, India has been a victim of cross-border terror, with Pakistan-based terror groups carrying out attacks in India. The 2008 Mumbai terror attacks, which killed over 160 people, were carried out by the Pakistan-based Lashkar-e-Taiba. The Indian government has consistently raised the issue of cross-border terror with its international partners, including the US. As India’s Maritime Security Lessons from Vietnam Tragedy notes, the threat of cross-border terror is not limited to land borders, but also extends to maritime security. In fact, India’s civilizational history is replete with examples of cross-border terror, including the invasion of India by the Ghaznavid Empire in the 11th century and the Mughal Empire’s expansion into India in the 16th century.
Implications for India-US Relations
The implications of Rubio’s response for India-US relations are significant. While the US has been a key partner for India in its fight against terror, Rubio’s downplaying of radical Islamist extremism raises questions about the US’s commitment to addressing this threat. As the world’s largest democracies, India and the US have a shared interest in combating terror and promoting regional stability. However, the US’s response to India’s concerns will be closely watched in the coming months. By next year, India will be closely watching the US’s actions on this front, and will expect a more robust response to the threat of cross-border terror. In fact, a report by the Center for Strategic and International Studies notes that the US and India have a shared interest in promoting regional stability in South Asia, and that cooperation on counter-terrorism is critical to achieving this goal.
Way Forward for India-US Cooperation on Counter-Terrorism
The way forward for India-US cooperation on counter-terrorism is clear. The US needs to acknowledge the threat of radical Islamist extremism and work with India to address this threat. This can be achieved through increased cooperation on intelligence sharing, counter-terrorism operations, and capacity building. In fact, a report by the Heritage Foundation notes that the US and India can cooperate on counter-terrorism by sharing intelligence on terror groups, conducting joint counter-terrorism operations, and providing training and capacity building to Indian security forces. Furthermore, the US can also support India’s efforts to promote regional stability in South Asia, including through the South Asian Association for Regional Cooperation (SAARC) and the Bay of Bengal Initiative for Multi-Sectoral Technical and Economic Cooperation (BIMSTEC).
In conclusion, India’s concerns about cross-border terror have been heard at the US meet, but the response from Senator Rubio has raised eyebrows. The implications of this response for India-US relations are significant, and the US needs to acknowledge the threat of radical Islamist extremism and work with India to address this threat. As India looks to the future, it will be closely watching the US’s actions on this front, and will expect a more robust response to the threat of cross-border terror. With a shared interest in promoting regional stability and combating terror, the US and India can work together to address this threat and promote peace and security in the region. In fact, a report by the Brookings Institution notes that the US and India can promote regional stability in South Asia by cooperating on counter-terrorism, promoting economic development, and supporting democratic institutions. By working together, the US and India can build a stronger and more stable South Asia, and promote peace and security for generations to come.
